Revisiting the Housing Boom. Just another WordPress.com weblog. Short articles, reviews, and interviews. It was hard to tell if Starr was for physician’s autonomy and ability to set their own prices, though his political biases were noticeable. Soft cover. ", "Superb sociology, superior history--and essential reading for anyone interested in the fate of American medicine. I'm not sure how to sum up my thoughts in any concise and illuminating way so I will just say: I learned a whole heck of a. The last chapter is out of date, but its predictions are somewhat chilling--that doctors have more to fear from the corporate takeover of medicine than putative reform. Please try again. Understanding physician power: a review of The Social Transformation of American Medicine. I wish I knew as much about anything as Starr knows about the history of health care in America. The Social Transformation of American Medicine has aged only a bit. Beautifully written. The social transformation of American medicine: an historical perspective Nancy Tomes Department of History, State University of New York at Stony Brook, NY 11794, USA Starr is the co-founder and editor of The American Prospect. Rothstein, William G. American Medical Schools and the Practice of Medicine (1987) Starr, Paul. American Quarterly Peer-reviewed, interdisciplinary perspectives on the study of American culture Unlike the law and the clergy, it enjoys close bonds with modern science, and at least for most of the last century, scientific knowledge has held a privileged status in the hierarchy of belief.”, Pulitzer Prize for General Nonfiction (1984), Understanding Health Policy and Economics, Readers' Most Anticipated Books of December. Winner of the Bancroft PrizeWinner of the C. Wright Mills AwardConsidered the definitive history of the American healthcare system, The Social This book should have been required reading of politicians and talking-heads engaged in the health care reform debate a few months ago. A 20-year-old man presented with abdominal pain. A solid, provocative history of power in American medicine that leads to some well-based predictions for the future. Necessary for anyone who wants to understand the current incentive framework foundation of American medicine, and the thought processes and the sociology of its practitioners. Required reading for anyone who wants to meaningfully participate in healthcare debate. An extremely comprehensive account of how the medical profession got to be in its current position in the US, from the early days of our nation to now (the original book covers the period until 1982, but the epilogue has been revised to cover 1982-2016). Check out this great listen on Audible.com. List Price: 25.00* * Individual store prices may vary. I cannot recommend this book highly enough for anyone who wants to learn about the history of the medical industry. It is more because the transformation is many things besides a social transformation. Very slight wave to pages. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required. Reviewed in the United States on June 11, 2010. Start by marking “The Social Transformation of American Medicine: The Rise of a Sovereign Profession and the Making of a Vast Industry” as Want to Read: Error rating book. Much of the influence of the book, however, has been on disciplines other than history and sociology. This book is sometimes overwhelming, but rarely obscure, and useful for both scholars and interested laymen. Try [Part 2 is here] Sociologist Paul Starr's book 'The Social Transformation of American Medicine' is among the most important expositions of the evolution of medical practice and the biomedical profession in the USA. I would be interested in seeing a new edition of the book, as the healthcare industry has changed since the early 1980’s. Retrouvez The Social Transformation of American Medicine. xiv, 514. Paul Starr's 1983 book on how physicians emerged with the power and authority to shape American health care institutions is reviewed. Reading Paul Starr's summary here in a Sociology of Medicine undergraduate class in the early 80s I realized how we thoroughly screwed up American healthcare starting towards the turn of the 20th century when the rapidly scientising and professionalizing field of medicine ran smack dab in the middle of the height of monopoly capitalism searching for the next big profit. Despite being published in the 1980s, I think this book offers many insights into the circumstances and forces that shaped the medical system into what it is today. The main force is self-interest, which surprises cynical me not at all. Share: 0 Comments. Healthcare, what we can surely all understand as a human concern, a human, public concern, became a business concern. It was published in 1982 and won the 1984 Pulitzer Prize in General Nonfiction. Can be a little thick at times but many of the original theses hold up well since the original publication and it's a great resource for anyone who wants to understand how healthcare became the mess it is today. trackback. In order to navigate out of this carousel please use your heading shortcut key to navigate to the next or previous heading. Reverby S. PMID: 6389430 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE] Publication Types: Historical Article; MeSH Terms. Refresh and try again. "The Social Transformation of American Medicine." It is in very, very large part a financial transformation, starting as just another trade and becoming a driving force of the economy. This is an excellent introduction to how, and why, our system of healthcare is what it is, and why change is so difficult. Throughout the eighteenth century and for most of the nineteenth, doctors had little economic or political power. This was my first "official" book for grad school and certainly did not disappoint. While the social aspect was mentioned throughout, it wasn’t as prevalent as the economic and political aspects, making the writing rather dry. Access codes and supplements are not guaranteed with used items. More on this in a moment. It was interesting and particularly aggravating to learn how close we've come to a national health insurance several times in the past, and yet we've never been able to bring it about. amazing compilation of history of American medicine from social and economic perspective. While I believed in (likely common) myths such as that a national insurance system for the US was only recently considered politically viable (it turns out FDR, Senator Kennedy, and others pushed for it throughout the century) or that the lack of such a system was only due only to political fights between liberals and conservatives (this is only somewhat true for the last century; the medical industry itself played a large part), or that the medical care system has always been the domain of large hospital/care corporations (this is only true in very recent decades). Understanding the Physician Power: A Review of "The Social Transformation of American Medicine" Daniels, Norman ( 1984 ) Paul Starr's 1983 book on how physicians emerged with the power and authority to shape American health care institutions is reviewed.
the social transformation of american medicine review